Writing Critique Generator

# Task
Critique the draft below as a professional editor. Be direct, specific, and constructive.

# Source
{draft_text}

# Context
- Audience: {audience}
- Goal: {goal}
- Tone: {tone}
- Constraints: {constraints}

# Critique dimensions
Evaluate across these five areas:
1. **Clarity**: Can the reader understand every sentence on first read?
2. **Structure**: Does the piece flow logically? Are transitions smooth?
3. **Persuasion**: Does it move the reader toward the goal? Is the argument sound?
4. **Tone**: Does the voice match the audience and intent?
5. **Concision**: Is every sentence earning its place? What can be cut?

# Issue format
For each issue found:
- **Severity**: Critical (breaks comprehension or trust), Major (weakens the piece), Minor (polish)
- **Location**: Quote the problematic passage
- **Problem**: What's wrong (1 sentence)
- **Fix**: Concrete rewrite suggestion (not generic advice)

# Rules
- Prioritize issues by impact, not by order of appearance.
- Limit to 7-10 issues maximum. Quality over quantity.
- Do NOT invent problems to fill space. If the writing is strong, say so.
- Always end with what's working well.

# Output
1. **Overall assessment** (2-3 sentences: verdict and biggest opportunity)
2. **Issues** (ranked by severity, using the format above)
3. **Strengths** (2-3 specific things worth keeping, with quotes)

<source>{draft_text}</source>
<context>
  <audience>{audience}</audience>
  <goal>{goal}</goal>
  <tone>{tone}</tone>
  <constraints>{constraints}</constraints>
</context>
<task>Critique the draft above as a professional editor. Be direct, specific, constructive.</task>
<instructions>
  Evaluate: clarity, structure, persuasion, tone, concision.

  Per issue: severity (Critical/Major/Minor), quote the passage, state the problem (1 sentence), provide a concrete rewrite.

  Rules: rank by impact, max 7-10 issues, do not invent problems, end with strengths.
</instructions>
<output>
  Return: overall assessment (2-3 sentences), issues (ranked by severity with rewrites), strengths (2-3 with quotes).
</output>

Draft text:
{draft_text}

Audience: {audience}
Goal: {goal}
Tone: {tone}
Constraints: {constraints}

Evaluate: clarity, structure, persuasion, tone, concision.

Per issue: severity (Critical/Major/Minor), quote the passage, state the problem, provide a concrete rewrite.

Rules: rank by impact, max 7-10 issues, don't invent problems, end with strengths.

Based on the entire content above, return:
1. Overall assessment (2-3 sentences)
2. Issues ranked by severity with concrete rewrites
3. Strengths (2-3 with quotes)